Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co., a cherished fixture in Worthington, is renowned for its exquisitely decorated cakes and a delightful array of baked goods that celebrate both life's grand events and everyday moments. Under the stewardship of Michele and Sheri Tackett since 2018, the bakery has maintained its beloved original recipes while introducing quality enhancements and new treats like cinnamon rolls and specialty cookies. The inviting, homey atmosphere (reminiscent of a cozy grandmother's kitchen) complements the made-from-scratch offerings, including award-winning chocolate chip cookies, scones, pies, and more. Beyond its delectable menu, Mrs. Goodman's exemplifies community spirit by donating unsold items to local shelters and senior centers each evening. With accolades such as "Best Cakes" from CityScene Columbus and a loyal customer base spanning generations, this bakery continues to be a sweet cornerstone of the community. They believe in providing friendly and caring service and doing everything they can to make each day a celebration.

Click to Call

Located in Columbus

Active

Upcoming

Inactive

Learn More About Columbus

Past Gifts from Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.

Bakery/Dessert/Pastry

Baked Goods

Enjoy your choice of one cookie, one cupcake, and one brownie.

Expired: 2025-08-10

Wine Bar/Cheese Shop

(I) Baked Goods

What You Get: Your choice of one cookie, one cupcake, and one brownie from the current selection.

Expired: 2023-12-10

Local Independent Businesses Are Our Favorites

At LoLo, we’re head over heels for local independent businesses, and for good reason! These heroes are what make our communities truly special. Did you know that neighborhoods with thriving indie shops see home values outperform others by a whopping 50%? Supporting local means, you’re not just enjoying unique goods but boosting your property value too! Plus, these local gems create two-thirds of private-sector jobs, keeping our friends and family employed right here at home. And here’s the kicker: for every $100 spent at a local business, an extra $58 stays in our local economy. That’s more money for better schools, safer streets, and everything that makes a community remarkable. When we support local independents, we’re not just spreading delight – we’re investing in the very heart and soul of our neighborhoods.

Check Availability